We left the dock in Mindelo, Cape Verde, at 6 a.m. on May 9, 2016, aboard the 78-foot Garlington Dreamin’ On, heading straight for Capt. Randy Hodgekiss’ favorite spot: the Northwest Banks. In the previous three days, we had great fishing, with catches of 500-, 650- and 750-pound blue marlin in the same area, and we released a 350-pounder about an hour before the big fish struck. We were raising an average of six blue marlin a day, but the smaller fish were hard to keep hooked — Dreamin’ On pulls large lures with pretty big hooks in the spread.
At 8:15 a.m., Hodgekiss asked me to take some pictures of the yellowfin tuna jumping out of the water around us. It looked really fishy, and the thought of a…