IN FEBRUARY OF 2018, the MeToo movement came for Hedley. On Twitter, stories about inappropriate encounters with the pop-rock band’s young fans began multiplying, including claims of sexual misconduct perpetrated by Jacob Hoggard, the lead singer. They soon numbered in the dozens. The band pushed back against the allegations, saying that, while they had, in the past, lived out what they called “certain rock and roll clichés,” there were lines they would never cross. But the tide had already turned. Within days, Hedley’s music was blacklisted from Canadian radio. Their management dropped them, and by the end of March, the band was on hiatus.
Then, in July, police charged Hoggard with three sexual offences involving two women in 2016. One of them alleged that, when she was in her early…