Matt Kramer brings up the issues related to scientism in a thoughtful and rational way. There is another point that scientism forgets. There was a time when science did not see things only through the reductionist mindset. In the beginning of the 20th century, scientific holism almost broke through. By its very nature, terroir is a holistic (in the true sense of the word) term. What cre-ates the sense of terroir is the sum total of all aspects of a given location: all soil pa-rameters, subsoil characteris-tics, latitude and longitude, exposure, elevation, solar radiation, seasonal wind speed, wind run, humidity. Beyond that, cultural, tradi-tional and historical markers are equally important con-tributors to terroir. It goes without saying that these lie beyond Matthews’ consideration.
Ted Lemon
Proprietor, Littorai Wines
Sebastopol, Calif.…