I MAKE NOTE-FOR-NOTE recreations on YouTube, and I also play bass in a tribute band. No one has ever come up after a live show and complimented the similarity of my tone or my parts to the originals, but on YouTube, particularly with guitar parts, viewers are extremely picky. People watching videos want to see you play and sound exactly like the original, and they call you out if you miss something, or if the tone is a little off. On video, where people can focus on a single part and rewind, the stakes are higher. In order to get shares, thumbs-up, and glowing comments, the notes, the feel, and the sound all have to be there.
It may seem paradoxical, but it is possible to nail a tribute performance…