On June 10, 2012, 42-year-old York, Pennsylvania, resident Spencer New-comer shot and killed his neighbor, 47-year-old David Wintermyer, in the culmination of a months-long dispute. Wintermyer, a former marine, had taken it upon himself to try to run New-comer out of the neighborhood by continuing to harass him, including the killing of a pet rabbit, vandalism and threats to his dog and girlfriend. The threats and harassment escalated, despite New-comer calling the police on Wintermyer on more than one occasion.
On the day in question, New-comer had decided to leave his house to get some errands done and attend a car show, and while he was pulling out of his driveway, Wintermyer exited his home, following New-comer onto the street and yelling and threatening to “kill his dogs.”
This direct…