Aluminum-bodied luxury cars, sport sedans, family sedans, an Australian-built V-8 sport coupe, minivans, a sub-$10K hatchback, a nouveauriche Vee-Dub, and a gas-electric hybrid: All are among the 26 new automobiles up for Motor Trend Car of the Year, 2004. It’s the most diverse field of contestants ever—and that creates challenges. How dare we compare the Pontiac GTO, BMW 5 Series, Acura TL and TSX, Nissan Quest and Toyota Sienna minivans, the premium-luxury Jaguar XJ8, Audi A8 L, and Volkswagen Phaeton, Chevy’s Aveo and Malibu, the Suzuki Verona, and the Toyota Prius, all in the same race for the Golden Calipers? We do it because that’s our job.
We take a big-tent approach to automotive enthusiasm. We know you’re most likely interested in cars like the 530i, GTO, Mitsubishi Evolution, and…