Petaluma, California It was an impossible choice. In July 2014, single mom Cathleen Cavin and her young daughter, Cali, visited Petaluma Animal Shelter and fell in love with twin kittens, Ozzie and Butter. Their landlord, however, would allow them to adopt only one. The Cavins picked Ozzie, never dreaming that—someday, somehow—the siblings would reunite.
The Dodo reports that two years later, Cathleen went on a date with Brian Herrera, a widower with a young daughter of his own, after months of chatting online. Cathleen was shocked to discover he owned a cat that was identical to Ozzie. The two compared adoption records: Brian had adopted Butter just four days after Cathleen took Ozzie home from the shelter.
The couple was already falling in love, but the discovery confirmed that they—like…
