Imagine a classroom full of 9th graders, say 27 of them. The teacher takes attendance and announces, “Good. Everyone’s here.” Having said this, a bewildered looking student in the back looks around the classroom and raises his hand.
“Yes, Stanton?” asked the teacher.
“Well, not everyone’s here. For example, I don’t see the President, the Spice Girls, or my dad,” replied Stanton, non-ironically.
We can stop here a moment. The sentence “Everybody’s here” is on the face of it ambiguous. Indeed, we could extend Stanton’s claim and say that everybody means everybody and most of the billions of people on this planet are not in that classroom. However, this is not how the vast majority of language users would interpret the teacher. Most of us would assume that the teacher…
