“The times in which Marxist socialism was a heresy to be stamped out with fire and sword are indeed over for the Catholic Church,” wrote Elisabeth Mann Borgese, daughter of the novelist Thomas Mann, in The Nation in January 1963. Headlined “The Church Embraces the Future,” her report detailed Pope John XXIII’s efforts to liberalize the church with the Second Vatican Council. “Turning [its] back on medievalism,” Mann Borgese wrote, “opens new possibilities of coming to terms with science and progress.”
John XXIII died a few months later and was succeeded by Pope Paul VI, who continued the reforms. “A new style of papacy is being created, a new frontier is being opened,” Mann Borgese wrote a year later.
“A closed, static, medieval organization cannot live in an open, dynamic,…
